Saturday, October 25, 2008

Has Nudism Lost Its Soul?

I was recently alerted to this article: Nudism - The Radical Tradition.
In the mid 1990's Hilary and I decided to join the "organised" naturist movement. From historical accounts of radical nudism I felt hopeful that we would meet some fellow spirits, or at very least a circle of intelligent, liberal, open-minded people. The general tone of CCBN literature and the fact that the organisation lacked a democratic constitution should have sent alarm bells ringing. Our first encounter with "organised" naturism was when we attended a CCBN swim where we found a preponderance of males. Where, we wondered, were all the naturist women? The idle conversation in the sauna revealed a very conservative membership far from our expectations. We winced at the homophobia and range of conservative prejudices on display. There was little evidence that this weekly, clandestine, social nudity encouraged the development of any real friendships outside the confines of the leisure centre. It did little to break down the social isolation of the naturist and certainly did nothing to influence ideas in the outside community. Clearly, all was not well with contemporary British naturism.
From my own experience, the same can be said about American nudism.

Let me preface my comments by saying that I see a lot of hope for naturism in America, particularly through the work of The Naturist Society, The Naturist Education Foundation and The Naturist Action Committee. Movements like The Body Freedom Collaborative exhibit some of that radical attitude that the writer found lacking in British Naturism. While the American Association of Nude Recreation espouses all the right naturist philosophies, the emphasis is more on the commercial nature of the lifestyle. And Clothes-Free International is all about selling memberships to get access to the photos and videos, but in the process they do manage to get out a positive message.

When I made my first visit to a nude swim in Columbus a couple of years ago, my first thought was "you need more women here". Males outnumbered females at least a 5 to 1 ratio, and oftentimes higher. While there is nothing inherently wrong in getting old (I'm 54), the average age of the men in the pool had to be about 60.

I'm glad I found the Columbus swims because they got me started in social nudism, but the events were so male dominated that I never felt comfortable bringing my wife, who resisted for a couple of years.

After every swim many of the participants gathered at a local pizza joint, and that was the extent of any real socializing. The pool venue was just a pool - there were no other facilities such as a sauna or exercise room to stimulate conversation. In the pool, like clockwork every swim, the water volleyball game dominated the evening. The sense that I got was that everyone was just going through the motions, putting plastic over the windows, setting up the net, starting the game, keeping score, and then tearing it down and covering the pool, and uncovering the windows.

I will say that the local Columbus swims are welcoming to anybody. If you are a single male interested in social nudism, it's a good starting point.

Certainly there is no apparent homophobia in the Columbus groups, since there are several gay men who participate without prejudice. I will say that at least one Midwest landed club openly discourages gay couples from attending, which is unfortunate.

Basically, nudism in Ohio is very socially isolated. Aside from some ads in naturist publications, and a crude web presence, most landed and non-landed clubs do very little to make contact with the outside world. From my experience, enthusiasm is often met with suspicion and skepticism, and an unwillingness to change.

Certainly, at least here in Ohio, social nudism needs to reinvent itself, or it will just fade away.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

5 comments:

Rick said...

I agree. Nudism in Ohio seems to have lost it soul. I share your frustrations with the club. Your experiences and reactions at the swims echo mine and I've found the the poor turn out at visits to landed clubs to be very disappointing.

I read in N and The Bulletin what other clubs are doing and wonder why "my" club isn't doing these things. I hear all the time how nudists bond together and form close friendships, yet I have yet to see or experience this first hand.

I wasn't able to attend the swim last weekend so I don't know what or if anything was decided. Even with the Google group and the blog available, there isn't much communication wiht the members. If I want to know anything I have to initiate it.

My membership has been up for renewal but I haven't gotten any notice to rewnew. I'm still debating whether or not being a member has any real value for me. I know I can't foster change unless I'm a member but the club has to want to change. I've seen how futile your efforts have been.

Yes, I think there is hope for nudism on a broader scale through the efforts of TNS< AANR, NAC, NEc, and other organizations. But nudism in Ohio seems to be on the decline.

Nudiarist said...

Thanks, Rick. Nobody feels sadder of more frustrated than me over all the wasted efforts with The Buckeye Naturists. Jim has a fatalistic attitude and refuses to do anything to make changes.

Anonymous said...

At Northcoast Naturists in Cleveland, we have a history of trying new and different activities to enable members to get to know each other. The men to women ratio is not much of an issue except at swims, maybe.

At swims we tend to be male dominated - three to one is not unusual. However, the club is largely run by couples. They have the ideas, the energy and the will to make the club work. Overall membership is 2:1 men to women, and most of the women come with partners.

At other social activities, extra men are not as noticeable. We just had a Halloween party. We have Thanksgiving Dinner coming up and plans are underway for a Christmas (or more generic Holiday) party in December. We do wine tastings - only four this year but we used to do them monthly. We also bowl twice a month.

What it takes is for some enthusiastic people to plan some activities and see what happens. At first you may only get small numbers attending, but as you get to know each other, and as word passes through the club of the fun you are having, more will join your active core. You will find different activities attract different people. It is critical to go out of your way to welcome people to activities and to make an effort to get to know them.

I will note that the baby boomer generation has been very active in organizing Northcoast and the club could probably use some younger people with fresh ideas.

Alan McIlwain,
Editor, The Naked Truth
(Northcoast newsletter)briteez

Anonymous said...

I was glad to see Alan's comments. Every month I see the Northcoast Naturists menetioned in The Bulletin's club happenings section. I have ties to the NE Ohio area so I belong to the Northeast Ohio naturist Yahoo group and see what's happening in that part of the state. I thnk it's noteworthy that they often participate in events sponsored by the West Penn Naturists.

Outside of a few people, I don't even know who are members of the club. Although don't live in the Columbus area, I'm willing to do what I can to promote activities or whatever.

I enjoy naturism and social nudism. I can be a naturist alone but it's the social aspect that makes it fun and really gives it meaning.

Anonymous said...

In Central Ohio we have a very active volleyball collective, scheduling ten events between here and Paradise Gardens in Cincy. The group goes to Tennessee, The Superbowl in Western PA. and we have just started a book club, Bare Naked Bibliophiles, that meets once a month.
This Saturday we watch the Buckeyes and the Wolverines in the buff, as we potluck and hot tub at a friend's beautiful home.
Sorry, you're not a part of our fun. I guess you gotta' put your ear to the ground.